Like many others, I was hooked from the first few minutes of The Unusuals. But at the same time I had this nagging feeling that my joy wouldn't last; not because the show was bound to disappoint, but rather that its network, ABC, would not have the patience to let its fandom grow. I had the strong sense that ABC had gotten spoiled with several instant mega-hits. Any new show that didn't immediately draw a following in the millions didn't stand a chance. And sure enough, just like the show it had replaced, The Unusuals never made it past its tenth show.
Now in the realm of entertainment, this is old news. So why am I bringing it up now? I am faced with the bizarre synchronicity of reveling in my recently acquired DVD of The Unusuals at the same time as I take my first plunge into the show, Southland. While completely different in most respects beyond the commonality of being cop shows, there is yet, at least for me, a similarity in feel between the two shows. I cannot pinpoint what this is, other than they hook me in the same way. But beyond this I am struck by the similarities in the shows' histories, and the glaring critical difference. Both are cop shows that aired on a broadcast network (The Unusuals--ABC; Southland--NBC) in April, 2009, both had a loyal following that was insufficient in numbers to keep their respective networks happy, and both shows wound up canceled. The vital difference? Southland was picked up by TNT. Its third season will be starting in January, 2011.
And now, as I am watching the first season of one show and the only season of the other, I can't help but wonder what might have been if The Unusuals had been picked up by a cable channel like TNT. Would I be enjoying or looking forward to its third season? It seems to me that TNT has greater patience for a growing show, greater willingness to let a show find its feet so that it might one day fly. Whether or not The Unusuals' quirkiness might have found a better fit on a cable network, we will now never know. Like many shows before and since, it exists only in the few episodes created before cancellation. And in our what might have beens.